Why didn't you answer with Yes/No?
Why didn't you answer with Yes/No? I thought this answer was great./villagepump/基素.icon
"Is Scrapbox a blog?" is a question that /villagepump/basic.icon would try to answer with "Yes/No".
It's amazing how you summarized what the blog was about, what its purpose was and what the challenges were, and developed what the future is in that context.
Why didn't I answer this question with a Yes/No?" The mystery of "Why didn't I answer Yes/No to this question?/villagepump/nishio.icon
It looked to me like it was because they were already thinking ahead./villagepump/inajob.icon
I made a note that "this topic sounds interesting," and finally got an answer after a while, so subjectively I don't feel like I "gave it out because I already had it."/villagepump/nishio.icon
What is Scrapbox? Have you asked yourself broad questions like that before?
I know what it feels like to answer a Closed question with an Open answer, as long as it's to the point. I know what you mean.
[clever
(Did I choose to say "clever" in a distant way?)
One wrong move and it's like [To someone with a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
The hammer, which can be used at any time to ask the question, "Is it A or B?"Balance is important 」w/villagepump/nishio.icon Hmmm, I think I might find something a little more interesting when I dig.
How do you use X and Y?" What is Y here? "Is X a Y?" That's how it went, wasn't it?
When Y is The concept is ambiguous, the question "Is X Y? I think the question "Is X Y?" is "Yes if Y is taken in a broad sense, and No if taken in a narrow sense. If there is an open discussion forum for Yes/No style questions, answering only Yes or No is not a discussion.
If options were only Yes and No, the conversation would not expand. It's like, "If it's condition A, then yes." "Well, if it's condition A, then yes."
How much does it mean to be Yes on the condition that A.
---
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/なぜYes/Noで答えなかったのか？ using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.