Panel 1:How can we enable the Plurality movement to improve our society?
hal_sk.iconThis is a social notes. Please contribute to take note!
Moderator
Panelists
Waka Itagaki Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, web3 research group Teruka Sumiya Project Specialist, Agile Governance, World Economic Forum, Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution Japan Notes
feel free to edit here!
Mashbean has also contributed the note not only for the panel but also for readers to understand Plurality in practice and Projects that use Plurality Note By mashbean brief. 単語群
Legitimacy:正当性、合法性
Panarchy:個人が移民や転居を伴わずにその所属する政府を自由に選択・変更することが出来る権利を主張する政治哲学
cf:anarchy:無政府状態
universal declaration of human rights:世界人権宣言
要諦:
【base】全人類が生まれながらに、人権を持っている。
【detail】人権には言論・信仰・教育などの種類がある。
【Action】ある政府が市民の人権を侵害しないように国際社会全体で協力しよう
poly-centric stewardship:多様な主体が共同で資源や環境などの管理・保全を行うこと
Audience guided topic.
How to apply Plurality to goverments (Q: "The current government is just not decentralized yet. Finaly, we can get some technic to take back ownership among each citizen? That's the art of governance".)
the question could be what techs can bring in
Plurality as one of the goals
"decentralization" is a means, one of the ways to make things happen.
style of decentralization is bottom-up / permissionless. Even in the digital world, it is power projection.
decentralize can be a tool fo Plurality
Bridge technology / democracy ("Plurality" identity, voting, funding in RxC) / moda Taiwan version 2 meanings interoperability, co-presence <all voices >)
Blockchain not necessary part of plurality (Q: "I feel the block chain is not the necessary part of plurality. How about this?")
g0v, hasn't used blockchain, one of the protocols or layers
a technology might not be a single, mandatory component
blockchain as time-stamping mechanism (to mitigate the risk of SPOF)
help shape in a friedlier direction (at 2:05:02 Q: what can someone do, as an individual, to help shape the Japanese regulations in a friendlier direction? (E.g: currently, taxes up to 55%, c2c trades taxable) ) advantages of web3 to be understood / changing regulations takes a lot of resources / always looking for use case that is socally beneficial.
digital nomads visa
(Seeing changes and movments in smaller organizations in such as DAOs may lead to Plurality). What leads to plurality? did anyone get it? akinorioyama.icon (invite more digital nomads, innovate with digital nomads. Normally, young people don't go to vote. If involved in DAO, they will have motivation to change the system, then go to government and politicians. They may feel they can make changes in the system. This kind of movement may lead to plurality.)
concept of plurality GOAL or means (at 2:10:30 Q: Do you think the concept of plurality (celebrating difference and cooperation) is at the level of GOAL, or merely means?) Plurality is placed as meta-paradigm.
Plurality is practical and Taiwan is trying to solve trilemma problem.
Focus on problem that can be solved in near future like 1 year.
collective intelligence project to find a solution toward a triangle,stagnation., technocrat , capitalism
Plurality can be goal and means simultaneously. Plurality can be a goal in the next stage where currently economic growth is a goal.
Plurality can be also attitude to perceive the world. The world is too complex to be dealt. Current technology and governance system can't handle the situation. Plurality technology could solve.
This is a required "condition" for sustainable society.
Taka: gov not decentralized. to take back owndership. Elaboration: gov to experiment techs. (at 2:16:05 Q: "The current government is just not decentralized yet. Finaly, we can get some technic to take back ownership among each citizen? That's the art of governance" ) "legitimacy". Topics,
QV, those good at appealing may win.
Digital transformation. People too occupied about daily life.
"The Network State" is a radical idea. Digital workld nation provides access. DAO as nation or nation as DAO. Pay tax to receive services. Technique of decentralized things. (clarify) DAO provide services. Public infrastructure provided by nation. Why people pay the tax for internet world. We need to pay more attention to how the techniques of the decentralized tools are used to make more public infrastructure to the world.
at 2:27:01 Q: Is it possible that small communities all over Japan play their own governance, and the central government govern as the governer of governers? analog government has a lot of assumptions. Smaller government such as DAO must have full transparency and accountability. "Making everything smartcontracts is the best way."
Social solidality economy (SSE). Famous in Africa or in South America. They have more alternative economies. It has cooperatives (people work together and share profits). For DAO, cooperative is the most important idea to collaborateeach other because democracy, not only voting, but also collaborating, We should learn from SSEs.
Public procurement can use many tools. Japan is still under ditital transformation. Goverenment lacks the ability to evaluate/measure the system's characteristics (system resiliency, etc.)
at 2:34:11 Q: governement friendliness of plurality enable technology that help coexistence of conflicting national interests? a new internation relation paradigm? Audrey Tang is leading the activities to promote the Plurality concept. Taiwan doesn't have official diplomacy, but the country still have a lot to do with academic, economic activites. W3C now has a new standard of decentralized identifier, not yet known to a wider audience. Examples may include e-resident. Taiwan still has a lot to work for digital transformation.
Audrey Tang sent Pull Request was used to relate.
Identify must be decentralized, but standardization. Choice is important even membership of W3C is needed.
identify standard, is scarcity. Decentralized ID is available, everyone, every organization can be become issueer. Value of the identity should be connected to the real world, Protection, tax payment, contribution to DAO.
Many DAOs, united DAO can accept voting from DAOs. diplomacy conflict. Conflict can be solved.Enemies will be there in any world. Crypto-diplomacy is our mission.
IMHO. Plurality, diversity. (at 2:41:20 Q: IMHO, Plurality is a word to describe one acpect of "diversity." I wonder why Plurality has become so popular in several years) Diversity is a noun. Plurality is a verb: use more methods like technology tools or democracy process to make diversity of the group, interest groups, stake holders to work together.
Audrey created vTaiwan together with other people. Pol.is is used for Uber deliberation. After discussion, people reached a rough consensus.
at 2:43:00 Q: Can DAO will work more like nation? Vitalik says in his blog that DAO needs to learn more in politics than in corporate goverenance. missed akinorioyama.icon formal logic. One malicious administration,then law won't work. Software-wise relationship should be created.
Vitalik discussed COVID-19 situation. Good for Concave problem. (Concave and Convex). Something such as border control for COVID-19 is not good for voting. For the distribution, this is good for democratic decision.
Measure Plurality initiattive (at 2:45:45, Q: How can we measure and evaluate the success of Plurality initiatives, and what do you think about the metrics and indicators we could use?) The item should be classified into either infallible problems or fallible problems. Plurality Falliable things.Infailable things, we still need to evaluate.
It is all about happiness. Happiness should be used to measure.
Cautious note of over-quantification and trying to measuring things. Quote: "If you can measure it's not intersting."
mashbean's memo for the panel